I asked if he knew anyone who hunted, that I was looking for wild game meat.
He said no, but that he shot squirrels.
He said he enjoyed shooting them. That they deserved it because they were invasive. That they were a nuisance, that they destroyed the bird feeder. And that it was fun.
He said please don't think less of me because I like killing squirrels.
And to maintain cordiality and to be truthful, I said well don't think less of me because I eat wild game.
But truth be told, I felt quite ill. I did not feel ill because he engages in the practice of killing other beings. We all do directly or indirectly, as part of our daily survival (except for those uncommon souls who survive only on air, and yes they are reported to exist). After all, the bird kills the worm, the cow kills the grass, the tiger kills the cow… and so on. And I do eat wild game, and wild fish and many a plant whose death I benefit from. So, I did not feel ill because he shoots squirrels.
So why did I feel ill?
Because of the implications of the words he said. The thought that taking another's life, removing the fire and spark from their body, was “fun”. The concept that because this somebody was not a human their existence was worth nothing - perhaps grounded in the Christian (and imperialist to me) belief that “God gave MAN dominion over all beings”. The idea that “being invasive” only applied to someone else, despite the speaker's own settler background. And that “being invasive” warranted extermination. The idea that destruction of an inanimate object not vital to the survival of anyone (the birds ate before the feeder and continue to eat in the face of its destruction) warrants execution. And the thoughts that lead someone to think they have the authority to act as enforcer and dole out punishment.
It is the same mindset behind manifest destiny and the settler colonial violence that went on long ago and is continuing in many places as I write these words. If I were to replace the word “squirrels” with any myriad of colonized, immigrant, oppressed and/or marginalized people, it seems to stem from the same failure to recognize the importance of all beings. Some people might say that the problem is the perpetrators view their victims as non-humans, no better than a pesky squirrel. But to me the problem is the supposition that the right to live and thrive only belong to one species.
Will I say something to this acquaintance? Probably not. I do not believe my words will have any bearing on his mindset or actions and may potentially do more harm than good. Will I condemn him and scowl when I see him? Absolutely not. I will treat him with the same kindness I try to treat everyone with. Do I dislike this man now or think he is a bad person? No, on the contrary he has always been consistently kind and helpful towards me. Do I think I am better or more virtuous than this man? Absolutely not. How can I when I know I have killed roaches in my home simply because “I did not want them there”.
I did not write these words to condemn this person who was vulnerable enough to share his viewpoint with me. After all, it is important to share, listen and hear others’ world views.
So why did I write these words? To release my feelings. Is that not one of the purposes of writing? And to release the Frio, the chill, that these words gave me:
“I like killing them, it's fun and they are an invasive nuisance”.
The chill is from the force of cruelty that the words reflect, a force that even lives inside of me at times.
To remind myself I now say once again, that the world is magnificent because of its diversity and no person nor species are better than the next, simply different.
May we all learn to act accordingly.
No comments:
Post a Comment