Tuesday, May 1, 2018

Yet Another Mascot - Shawnee Mission North Indians

Dear Ms. _________,

I hope this message finds you well.  Thank you for all the fine work you do with students and the community.  SMSD is one of the greatest in the country because of dedication, focus, diligence and savvy.

It is because SMSD is so great that I am writing this letter.  The schools and district have a reputation for being full of erudite and progressive people.  So naturally I was surprised when I went to a high school football game and heard to the announcer call out "Shawnee Mission North Indians".  I was hoping I had misheard, but my fears were confirmed when I saw someone with a shirt bearing a man in headdress.

I wanted to share with you how I feel when I see high school teams using " Indian Mascots": a combination of anger, disgust, sadness and hurt.

Anger that for some reason in 2017 Native American people are not seen as living, breathing, diverse humans but as a dead, historical, homogeneous and irrelevant peoples.

Disgust that a place that is responsible for educating the youth is perpetuating such images and phraseology as acceptable.

Sadness for the Shawnee people who were forcibly removed from their eastern homelands to the Midwest. Sadness for the Shawnee children were forcibly removed from their homes and made to attend boarding schools such as the Shawnee Mission school.  Their languages and traditions were forbidden.  They were beaten and raped.  They were isolated from their families, not allowed to see them for long periods of time. 

Hurt that Native American peoples and nations seem to be the only group singled out for this type of treatment.  Where are the Shawnee Mission North Negroes?  The Shawnee Mission North Jews?  The Shawnee Mission North Whites?  People would never allow such an outrage.  However they think nothing of the Shawnee Mission North Indians.  

I also had a new feeling this evening:  Disappointment.  SMSD is better than that.

Thank you for reading my long message.  Some will agree, some will dismiss it, some will get mad and say the mascots are "honoring" and "tradition". Some will say it costs too much to change.  Some will perhaps seek out Native people who like and/or are in support of Indian mascots.  I am aware of all of these things.  However I leave you with the thoughts:

1.  What sort of images and teachings  do SMSD want to promote?

2.  Equality in mascots.  If a team called the "Shawnee Mission North Jews" seems inappropriate, so is the "Shawnee Mission North Indians". If there are no teams called the "Shawnee Mission North Hispanics" or team mascots with caricatures of Asian, African American or White people, there should be none with Native people.  End of story. 

With much appreciation,

Maura Garcia, MFA

No comments: