"Flash Judgments About Race & Identity"
A Letter to a Friend
Many like to think that they can identify a person's "race" based on their appearance and neatly place them into racial categories based on certain features. People are often correct in their guesses OR unaware of when they are not. Sometimes people's inner observations and assumptions have no effect on the subject what so ever. Other times these assumptions do have an negative effect on the subject and for that reason I believe assuming you know someone's "race" is a bad and harmful habit.
As of course I know you know, race does not exist in scientific terms and most ethnic categories include lots of continental mixture resulting in numbers of people who are interchangeable between any "race". As you also know, these categories are not static and switch and change depending on laws, societal norms and self-identification. Thankfully in this day and age we are allowed (at least by law) to determine which ethnic group we are a member of without having someone assign us a place.
I suppose this is a real sticking point for me because I understand how it feels to be misidentified by people who say they can just "tell". I am American Indian and many people classify me as African American. I understand this mistake because it has a historical basis in the attempt to eradicate and disenfranchise Native peoples by:
1. limiting the number of recognized Indians via the introduction of blood quantum rules and ideas that Indians mixed with African blood are magically not Indian
2. the attempt to subjugate greater numbers of people by "one drop of African blood" rules
3. the inability to understand that being of African descent does not necessarily determine your "racial" category.
The reality is that there are people of African descent in every "racial" category and have been at least for 500 years. Other mistakes have been made and are potentially offensive and/or harmful. When I lived in Florida and while traveling through NYC, people assumed that I was Latina based solely on my appearance. They expected me to have certain ideas and attitudes based on their presumptions. While living in Washington, DC, many Ethiopians assumed I was one of them and I experienced prejudice for not claiming my supposed Ethiopian heritage. I have been spit upon because I was supposedly pretending to not be Arab. I have been accused of hiding my Moroccan origins. Light-skinned American Indian, African American and Latino friends of mine have been assumed white by others of their own ethnic group and have suffered pain as a result. I have dark-skinned Latino friends who are told they have to be Black and that the ethnicity of their birth is no longer their's. I have Iranian acquaintances who are constantly misidentified as Latinos and who tire of not being seen for themselves.
I am well aware that in the scope of the problems of the world, assuming you know someone's ethnicity is a small issue. I also am aware that it is a very common problem that may take alot of work to change and that may never fully end. However, based on my experiences and those of many other people, I believe it there is something oppressive about trying to tell people who and what they are. We all strive to be understood and recognized for who we are and any attempt to deny us that right is often upsetting and sometimes traumatic. Attempting to assign people racial categories without asking them is a small act of violence. Whenever I come up against it, I will continue to work towards a world where we ask one another our ethnicity if the need arises. As Sweet Honey in the Rock once said "Freedom is being able to define ourselves."
Love you very much,
Maura
No comments:
Post a Comment